I realize my statements have triggered some of you and I’d like to reinforce my last sentence in this statement. What I’ve seen on this forum is guys who look for improvement vs. simply replacing with similar components.
The issue I’ve run into with vintage is it doesn’t play nice with new gear due to the higher noise floor. Improvements in manufacturing, capacitors, resistors, power transformers, component isolation inside, vibration control implementations, internal wiring choices and design, and many other factors drop the noise floor significantly and allow better separation in the soundstage. When you modify vintage, you can begin to address some of these shortcomings. This includes things like phono carts etc.
For what it’s worth, there are also brands that I refuse to carry because they suffer the same issues. In the systems I build these shortcomings are very apparent and when clients try my pieces in vintage rigs, they are greatly hindered. We have had zero success integrating new and old unless the vintage pieces have some extra work and money poured into them.
This is NOT to say one way is wrong or the other. This is a hobby and should be fun, not maniacally correct. Much like tuners vs muscle, just do you and enjoy it.