The Coral "holey basket" thread

 
Ya beat me to it!

I do, however, think there's an error in his write-up - he says he used the 0.36 cu ft cabinets, but there doesn't appear to be any of that internal volume - there is, however, a 0.23 cu ft cabinet which features the same photo as in that thread:

https://www.parts-express.com/denovo-audio-knock-down-mdf-023-cu-ft-mini-bookshelf-speaker-cabinet--300-7062

I'm unsure as to which of the four varieties of 4" passive radiators were used in that build, but this appears to be the cheapest:

https://www.parts-express.com/dayton-audio-ds115-pr-4-designer-series-passive-radiator--295-493
 
I have a pair of black cone, a pair of the tan cone with no dust covers for some yet to be turned phase plugs, and a single tan cone.

I have the black cone pair in some boxes I made that are very nearly the Fostex Fe103 bass reflex that's on the datasheet for that driver. They sound fantastic, not much bass, but with a decent BSC the bass improves a bit.


View attachment 19049


IIRC the bsc I tested was 1mH with ~5 or ~10ohm across it... that was a year or so ago, so I could be way off... there are several basic bsc calculators on the web that simply use the baffle width to calculate. The bass improved noticeably with the bsc in place. It was a quality inductor, and an Mills MRA-12.. I'll see if I can find a picture with it...
@gable - is that a kit cabinet or one you built yourself? Wondering how you got that fantastic looking baffle.

(also a gentle nudge about the BSC)
 
Last edited:
@gable - is that a kit cabinet or one you built yourself? Wondering how you got that fantastic looking baffle.

(also a gentle nudge about the BSC)


I built it, it's an easy build. I'll dig up the dimensions that I used a little later tonight.

The baffle is just MDF. I rear mounted the driver because their frames are terrible looking. I added a bit of a roundover to the front side, then sanded, carefully with the orbital, and by hand to soften to transition from the round-over to the baffle. Use 220 grit or higher so you don't remove too much material at once, and light pressure.

After I'm happy with that, I do a light pass of 220, 320 with the orbital, then move to 400 on a flexible block. Once its sanded nice and smooth, I just rubbed in a bunch of Howards Feed and Wax.

The real trick with mdf is the damn edge grain, I block sand with 400 quite a bit, then will sometimes rub in some mineral oil over the surface, especially the edge grain, let it soak in as much of that as possible, wipe of the excess, then apply the wax.

It's actually easier than it sounds.


oh, and BSC, baffle step compensation, IIRC. An inductor, with a resistor across it, in series with the positive + terminal of the driver. It can help improve the bass response, by basically attenuating the upper mid/hf a bit. They can work very well. There are plenty of good calculators around, I'll try to dig some up for ya.
 
I'm thinking about picking up a pair of these cabinets.
They're a little bigger, but still very inexpensive.
 
Just stumbled upon this thread. I want to say that I absolutely love the Holey Baskets in my Frugal Horn MkIII's. They replaced the respectable Fostex FE124En but are far better in every way. Before the Frugal Horns I tried them in OB's over H-frame Alphas and I could have lived with that combo but now they're staying in the horn enclosures. I don't think I have enough posts yet to attach a picture. Plans are free for the Frugal Horns and at diyaudio there's a lengthy thread on them.
 
Just stumbled upon this thread. I want to say that I absolutely love the Holey Baskets in my Frugal Horn MkIII's. They replaced the respectable Fostex FE124En but are far better in every way. Before the Frugal Horns I tried them in OB's over H-frame Alphas and I could have lived with that combo but now they're staying in the horn enclosures. I don't think I have enough posts yet to attach a picture. Plans are free for the Frugal Horns and at diyaudio there's a lengthy thread on them.

Damn, this makes me wonder if some of my coral's would work in my BK-12 BLH's. The FHmk3 works well for the FE126, which are the drivers I have in my BK-12's. I may have to try this.

The little corals are certainly something special.
 
So I picked up a second set, have to sep them from their original cabinets. Before I do I’ll be listening to them to see how they sounded once upon a time and comparing to their new cabinets once done. More to come!
 
Damn, this makes me wonder if some of my coral's would work in my BK-12 BLH's. The FHmk3 works well for the FE126, which are the drivers I have in my BK-12's. I may have to try this.

The little corals are certainly something special.

Since the Corals don't fit in the same size hole as the FE126En's I had to fashion a supra baffle on top of the original cut outs. My supra baffle is nothing more than a plaque from Michaels glued to the face of the horns. The Corals are so efficient I drive them with an original APPJ/MW that makes all of 2.5 watts. I think it's the perfect driver for a back loaded horn enclosure.
 
Since the Corals don't fit in the same size hole as the FE126En's I had to fashion a supra baffle on top of the original cut outs. My supra baffle is nothing more than a plaque from Michaels glued to the face of the horns. The Corals are so efficient I drive them with an original APPJ/MW that makes all of 2.5 watts. I think it's the perfect driver for a back loaded horn enclosure.

That's what I was thinking, making a supra baffle for the corals. I'll be driving them with my 1626 Darling, ~750mW.
 
Since the Corals don't fit in the same size hole as the FE126En's I had to fashion a supra baffle on top of the original cut outs. My supra baffle is nothing more than a plaque from Michaels glued to the face of the horns. The Corals are so efficient I drive them with an original APPJ/MW that makes all of 2.5 watts. I think it's the perfect driver for a back loaded horn enclosure.
I'm assuming this one: https://www.michaels.com/pine-circle-plaque-by-artminds/10067602.html
 
Damn, this makes me wonder if some of my coral's would work in my BK-12 BLH's. The FHmk3 works well for the FE126, which are the drivers I have in my BK-12's. I may have to try this.

The little corals are certainly something special.
I wonder if Madisound would sell the BK-12 BLH cabinet sans FE126En drivers...
 
Since the Corals don't fit in the same size hole as the FE126En's I had to fashion a supra baffle on top of the original cut outs. My supra baffle is nothing more than a plaque from Michaels glued to the face of the horns. The Corals are so efficient I drive them with an original APPJ/MW that makes all of 2.5 watts. I think it's the perfect driver for a back loaded horn enclosure.

Could you possibly give some comparisons between the Coral and your Lowther?
 
Back
Top